Final answer:
The narrator loathes the silent girl out of jealousy, feeling inferior when comparing herself to Janey's perceived beauty and grace. Other students seem to sympathize with the silent girl, recognizing the unique qualities in the man associated with her. The correct answer to the question seems to be (A): The narrator finds her annoying; other students sympathize with her.
Step-by-step explanation:
The narrator expresses a loathing towards the silent girl because she sees beauty and grace in another, which contrasts with her own perceived deformity and dullness. The narrator's dislike is rooted in jealousy and an acute self-awareness of her differences. While we aren't given explicit details about the other students' views, the extended narrative suggests that they recognize something unique about the man, alluding to a possible sympathy or acknowledgement of the silent girl's situation by association.
The text conveys a complex interplay of emotions and perceptions among the characters, suggesting that the silent girl's presence evokes different reactions based on the individual's perspective. The other students are described as having a certain distance, indicating either a lack of understanding or a deliberate avoidance. With the given options, the most plausible answer to the question seems to be (A): The narrator finds her annoying; other students sympathize with her.