Final answer:
An author's effectiveness in counter-arguments relies on the use of evidence, acknowledging and refuting counterclaims, and addressing the rhetorical situation, including a strong conclusion that revisits the thesis or reflects the writer's stance.
Step-by-step explanation:
In evaluating whether an author's counter-arguments are effective in proving her own point of view, one must consider if the author fully addresses and refutes the counterclaims. This entails examining the evidence presented, the logic and credibility of the arguments, and whether any relevant points have been omitted. An effective response to counterarguments establishes the writer's credibility by demonstrating fairness and the ability to appeal to the readers' logic and emotions. A skilled author like Lily Tran would methodically look for weak spots in the opposition's argument to refute them, sometimes even using the opposition's language to indicate a close and critical reading of their claims.
Additionally, the paper’s structure must also reflect the writer’s understanding of the rhetorical situation, which involves being aware of the audience, purpose, and context of the argument. To fully and forcefully address a counterargument, Lily Tran could enhance her writing by integrating more pathos to connect emotionally with the reader or by using stronger, more decisive language to make her rebuttal more compelling.
In conclusion, revisiting and reinforcing the thesis at the end of the essay can be an effective strategy to leave readers with a lasting impression. However, Lily Tran might also consider employing other methods such as a call to action, posing a rhetorical question, or forecasting future implications of her argument to strengthen her conclusion and give readers something significant to ponder.