177k views
4 votes
2. Both Antigone and Socrates carry out acts that they know will result in their death: Antigone burying her brother, and Socrates continuing to teach, not leaving Athens when he had the chance. How would you compare the reasoning behind their decisions? Do you think Antigone and Socrates would have appreciated each other's actions?

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Antigone's decision to bury her brother reflects her commitment to divine over human laws, while Socrates' refusal to flee prison is rooted in his dedication to the pursuit of wisdom and the integrity of the soul. Despite differences, both acted according to deeply held principles, and it's likely they would have respected each other's choices.

Step-by-step explanation:

Both Antigone and Socrates made decisions that ultimately led to their deaths, but their reasons for doing so were fundamentally different yet connected by a commitment to certain principles. Antigone buries her brother because she believes in following the eternal laws of right and wrong, which for her override Creon's edicts. This decision underscores her devotion to familial duty and divine laws over human ones.

Socrates, on the other hand, continues his philosophical inquiries and teaching despite the danger because he values the quest for wisdom and the integrity of the soul above the fear of death. His refusal to escape from prison stems from a deep adherence to social contracts and the belief that escaping would be unjust to the laws of the state, which he had agreed to live by. Both would likely have honored each other's commitment to their principles. Antigone might admire Socrates' steadfast dedication to the truth and moral integrity, while Socrates could see Antigone's actions as a stand for a higher moral law.

User Magzalez
by
8.2k points