Question

In the western United States, elk populations are at an all-time high. In some states, the state government has established elk feedgrounds, where elk gather in large numbers during the winter to eat hay provided by the state. This enables more elk to survive the winter, elevating the population even further. Some people are in favor of closing the feedgrounds. What might some of the arguments be for closing the feedgrounds? What might some be for keeping them open?

Option 1: Arguments for closing the feedgrounds include concerns about disease transmission among crowded elk and the unnatural concentration of animals. Arguments for keeping them open revolve around elk survival and viewing opportunities.
Option 2: Some reasons to close feedgrounds include the risk of disease spread and ecological disruption, while keeping them open may be seen as a way to support elk populations and tourism.
Option 3: Arguments to close the feedgrounds involve disease control and ecological balance, while keeping them open is supported for elk conservation and wildlife watching.
Option 4: People may advocate closing the feedgrounds due to disease concerns and ecological impact, whereas keeping them open is favored for elk population management and tourism benefits.

Answer 1

Closing elk feedgrounds can help control disease transmission and maintain a more natural population distribution. However, keeping them open supports elk survival and provides wildlife viewing opportunities.

Step-by-step explanation:

Arguments for closing the feedgrounds include concerns about disease transmission among crowded elk and the unnatural concentration of animals. Closing the feedgrounds can help control the spread of diseases and maintain a more natural population distribution. On the other hand, arguments for keeping the feedgrounds open revolve around the survival of the elk and the opportunities they provide for wildlife viewing. The feedgrounds help ensure that elk have enough food to survive the winter and allow people to observe these animals up close.