Final answer:
Law enforcement should be called upon in an IR or DR situation when there is illegal activity involved. Issues with such involvement can include risks to privacy, operational interference, and requirements to disclose sensitive information. Solutions involve clear policies and weighing legal obligations against civil liberties.
Step-by-step explanation:
Law enforcement should be involved in an Incident Response (IR) or Disaster Recovery (DR) action when there are indications of illegal activity, such as data breaches involving theft of sensitive information or attacks on critical infrastructure. Involving law enforcement can help in investigating the incident, collecting evidence, and pursuing legal action against the offenders.
The issues associated with law enforcement involvement include potential risks to privacy and civil liberties, the possibility of interference with operations, and the requirement to disclose sensitive company information. These potential issues necessitate careful consideration of the implications of involving law enforcement in IR or DR activities.
Previously proposed solutions to weighing the decision to involve law enforcement often revolve around clear policies and procedures, legal counsel, and balancing legal obligations with privacy concerns. These solutions have had varying success based on the organization's adherence to these policies and the legal landscape they operate in. The implementation often resides with corporate governance, legal departments, or compliance officers.
Questions Related to Limiting Action and Civil Liberties
To assess whether a limit on action represents an inappropriate infringement of civil liberties, one might consider the effectiveness of past solutions, the reasons for their success or failure, and who has the authority to enforce such solutions.
Regarding voter ID laws, many argue that they can hurt democracy by potentially disenfranchising eligible voters. The debate about whether felons should vote after serving their sentences ties in closely with civil liberties, discussions of democracy, and the reintegration of individuals into society.