147k views
2 votes
What is the question statement for the given DS - Affirming the Disjunct (INVALID) question?

1) True
2) False

User PatricNox
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The question deals with a philosophical concept named Affirming the Disjunct, a logical fallacy where a conclusion is incorrectly affirmed due to the truth of one part of a disjunction.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question asks about Affirming the Disjunct, which is a type of logical fallacy and pertains to the field of philosophy, specifically within a branch called logic. This concept is not valid because it involves an incorrect inference. In a disjunctive syllogism, the argument is structured such that if one disjunct (part of a disjunction) is true, the other must be false. The fallacy of Affirming the Disjunct occurs when one assumes that because one disjunct is true, it then affirms the truth of the conclusion without legitimate grounds. For the statement to be considered true, it has to follow the proper logical form. An example of a valid disjunctive syllogism would be: 'Either X is true or Y is true. X is true. Therefore, Y is not true.'

When it comes to identifying the validity of statements in conditional reasoning and disjunctive syllogism, it is essential to understand the logical structures involved and recognize when a fallacy arises due to a false dichotomy or an error in deduction.

User ExxKA
by
7.9k points