Final answer:
To help Juliette with her critique, she should start with a description of the piece, proceed to an analysis that identifies themes and character motivations, and then evaluate the piece's effectiveness.
Step-by-step explanation:
The best advice for Juliette to help her with her critique would be to start with a description of the piece. Describing the piece will provide a foundation for her analysis and interpretation. Once the description is in place, Juliette can move on to interpreting the work by identifying major themes or ideas, any contradictions to those themes, and the nuances of character motivations and the narrator's perspective. She should consider how words and visuals work together if applicable, and assess the trustworthiness of sources and evidence supporting the main point. Only after a thorough understanding can she evaluate the piece effectively. It's also beneficial for Juliette to outline key passages and plan which aspects she will focus on in her critique.
Juliette should engage with the text through multiple readings and annotations, tracking any patterns or symbols that emerge. As she contemplates the text, she should ask herself questions that delve into the 'how' and 'why' aspects, going beyond surface-level responses. Through this process, Juliette can practice and apply strategies such as interpretation, response, and critique, compose a solid argument, and integrate her ideas with those from appropriate sources while maintaining the focus on her interpretation of the literary work rather than just summarizing it.