Question

Do you think Martin Luther or Henry VIII had a better reason to break with the church?

1) Martin Luther
2) Henry VIII
3) Both had valid reasons
4) Neither had a valid reason

Answer 1

Both Martin Luther and Henry VIII had valid reasons to break with the church, but their reasons were different. Martin Luther objected to the Catholic Church's practices, while Henry VIII wanted to annul his marriage and have more control over the Church in England.

Step-by-step explanation:

Martin Luther and Henry VIII both had valid reasons to break with the church, but their reasons were different.

Martin Luther criticized Church leaders in the Vatican due to his dissatisfaction with the Catholic Church's practice of selling indulgences and his objection to other questionable practices. He believed that faith alone was needed for salvation and that scripture was the only source of Christian authority.

On the other hand, Henry VIII rejected the authority of the Catholic Church because he was angry that the pope would not annul his marriage to Catherine of Aragon. Additionally, he wanted to have more control over the Church in England and separate from the influence of the pope.

While both Luther and Henry VIII had valid reasons based on their own beliefs and circumstances, they had different motivations and goals in breaking with the church.