185k views
3 votes
In which situation would a writing be required?

1) Mason calls a cleaning service for his four-month stay in a New York apartment starting in ten months.
2) Mason calls Maverick Airlines to purchase airline tickets to New York for $500.
3) Raul orders custom-made cabinets for his office, and the cabinet maker begins substantial work.
4) Darrel telephones a computer store and orders a $1,000 computer for pickup. He subsequently picks up the computer and makes payment.

User Teena
by
8.0k points

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

A written agreement is most likely required when Mason arranges a cleaning service for his four-month stay at a New York apartment starting in ten months, due to the Statute of Frauds since it involves real estate and extends beyond a year.

Step-by-step explanation:

The situation in which a writing would be required can depend on various factors, including the value of the transaction and its nature. For example:

  • If Mason calls a cleaning service for a four-month stay in a New York apartment starting in ten months, a written agreement could be deemed necessary because the service agreement involves real estate and extends beyond a one-year period, which generally triggers the Statute of Frauds requirement for a written contract.
  • For purchasing airline tickets to New York for $500, a writing is typically not required due to the immediate nature of the transaction and the fact that most ticket purchases are done electronically or with immediate proof of purchase.
  • Ordering custom-made cabinets where the cabinet maker begins substantial work often involves a contract, especially if it is a high-priced item. The custom nature of the work and the implication that the work cannot be readily sold to others would suggest that a writing may be necessary to ensure the specifications and terms are clear.
  • Buying a $1,000 computer for pickup typically necessitates a receipt or proof of purchase, but not a formal written contract beyond that which is directly related to the sale transaction.

In conclusion, among the scenarios provided, the situation involving a real estate transaction (the cleaning service) for a period longer than one year would most likely require a written agreement due to the obligations such a service entails.

User Jorn Van Dijk
by
8.4k points