213k views
4 votes
Do you think Moishe's statement, "Man asks, and God replies. But we do not understand His replies. We cannot understand them," is a contradiction?

User GOVarney
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

According to Maimonides, human beings cannot understand God's replies due to the finite nature of human knowledge compared to God's infinite knowledge and power.

Step-by-step explanation:

Maimonides, a Jewish philosopher, argued that human beings cannot understand God's replies because His knowledge and power are infinite, while human knowledge is finite and quantifiable. Maimonides proposed a negative theology, stating that humans can only ascribe attributes to God's actions and not His essence. Therefore, Moishe's statement reflects Maimonides' belief and is not a contradiction, but rather an acknowledgment of the limitations of human understanding in relation to God.

User Foolbear
by
7.1k points