25.9k views
4 votes
Melinda says "my room belongs to an alien?" What does she mean? Describe her room in detail to help explain. (speak novel)

Option 1: Her room is filled with extraterrestrial objects
Option 2: Her room feels unfamiliar and strange
Option 3: Her room is painted with alien symbols
Option 4: Her room is frequented by creatures from another planet

User Matt Sich
by
7.4k points

1 Answer

3 votes

In the context of the novel "Speak" by Laurie Halse Anderson, Melinda's statement "my room belongs to an alien" is not meant to be taken literally. Instead, it's a metaphorical expression that reflects her inner emotional state and her perspective on her surroundings. The language used throughout the novel is often symbolic and expressive of Melinda's emotional journey as she deals with the aftermath of a traumatic event.

Given the options provided:

Option 1: Her room is filled with extraterrestrial objects - This is unlikely, as there's no indication in the novel that Melinda has an interest in such objects or that her room is decorated in this way.

Option 2: Her room feels unfamiliar and strange - This is the most plausible interpretation. Melinda is experiencing a sense of alienation and disconnection from her environment and herself after the traumatic incident. Her room, which should be a personal and familiar space, may feel foreign to her because she herself feels changed or disconnected from her pre-trauma identity.

Option 3: Her room is painted with alien symbols - Similar to option 1, there's no evidence in the novel to suggest that Melinda's room has been painted with alien symbols or that she has engaged in any behavior that would support this interpretation.

Option 4: Her room is frequented by creatures from another planet - This is clearly not the case, as the novel does not delve into science fiction or fantasy; it is rooted in the real and challenging experiences of a teenage girl.

Based on the emotional narrative of the novel, we can conclude that Option 2 is the correct interpretation of Melinda's statement. Her room feeling unfamiliar and strange signifies her dissociation and the transformative impact the traumatic event has had on her life. The sense of strangeness in her own space reflects a broader theme of her feeling like an outsider in her own life and in relation to others around her.

User EvilGenious
by
8.4k points