163k views
1 vote
Sarah described the following situation:

When more apples grew in the backyard, the pet cat stayed indoors for a longer time.
Which of the following best describes the situation?
This is an example of correlation because there is an obvious relationship between the two scenarios.
This is an example of causation because apples cause cats to stay indoors.
This is an example of correlation because apples cause cats to stay indoors.
This is an example of causation because cats dislike apples.
Question 6 (multiple choice worth 1 point)

User Jaanhio
by
7.2k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The described scenario between apple growth and cat behavior is an example of correlation, not causation, which only implies a relationship, not that one event causes the other. It's important to consider confounding factors that might influence both observed variables when evaluating such relationships.

Step-by-step explanation:

The situation described with Sarah observing that when more apples grew in the backyard, the pet cat stayed indoors for a longer time is an example of correlation, not causation. In this context, correlation means that there is a relationship between the growth of apples and the behavior of the cat, but it does not imply that the apples directly cause the cat to stay indoors. It is possible that both events could be influenced by a third factor or that their association is simply a coincidence.

An illustrative example of correlation versus causation can be drawn from studies showing that as ice cream sales increase, so do burglary rates. It would be incorrect to assert that one causes the other; instead, it is likely that warm weather is the confounding factor which increases both ice cream consumption and crimes like burglaries. Similarly, just because two trends appear to coincide, like the apparently greater apple abundance and the cat's indoor preference, we cannot infer a direct causal relationship without further investigation or controlling for confounding variables.

User Bangkok Apartment
by
7.6k points