Final answer:
In this statement, the student suggests that Tibbet's story is better than expected, and Mr. Fisher's reaction is extreme. The extent to which this is agreed upon is subjective and depends on interpretation.
Step-by-step explanation:
In the given statement, the student claims that Tibbet's story is better than Mr. Fisher expected, and Mr. Fisher's reaction is extreme. To what extent I agree with this statement is subjective and depends on interpretation. However, it is possible that Mr. Fisher's extreme reaction could indicate that the quality of Tibbet's story surpassed his expectations. This could be seen as a positive aspect of Tibbet's storytelling abilities.