Final answer:
Old forms of punishment like whippings may have been effective historically, but they would not be considered effective or acceptable in modern society due to the evolution of legal and ethical standards that prioritize human rights and rehabilitation over mere deterrence.
Step-by-step explanation:
In considering whether old forms of punishment such as whippings and floggings would be effective in modern times, it's important to recognize the progression of societal values and the legal system. Historical punishments often served to exert control and instill fear, as seen in the treatment of slaves where physical violence and threats of separation from family were common.
While these methods were effective in creating an immediate deterrent, they were not efficient due to the incapacitation or death they could cause. Today, the justice system focuses more on a balance between punishment and rehabilitation, with a strong emphasis on human rights as ensured by the Eighth Amendment. This enlightened approach believes in sophisticated methods that aim to reintegrate offenders into society rather than simply inflicting pain or fear.
Controversial views on corporal punishment still exist, with some arguing that it can be an effective disciplinary measure, while studies and expert opinions suggest it may lead to aggression and further antisocial behaviors. Hence, many U.S. schools have banned such practices, and the Constitution protects citizens from cruel and unusual punishment, including torture.
In conclusion, it is unlikely that such old styles of punishment would be considered effective or acceptable in today's society, primarily due to the evolution of legal and ethical standards.