170k views
0 votes
Argument or Nonargument ?

Any part of a plant that bears seed for reproduction is a fruit. Tomatoes and cucumbers bear seed for their plants' reproduction. Therefore, it must be the case that tomatoes and cucumbers are fruits.

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The provided statement is an argument stating that since any part of a plant that bears seeds is a fruit, and tomatoes and cucumbers bear seeds, they must be fruits. Botanical definitions of fruit include the various methods by which they are formed, and their role in seed dispersal.

Step-by-step explanation:

Is the Statement an Argument or Nonargument?

The statement provided is an example of an argument because it presents a set of premises followed by a conclusion that is logically derived from those premises. The premises are that any part of a plant that bears seeds for reproduction is classified as a fruit, and that tomatoes and cucumbers bear seeds for their plants' reproduction. The conclusion then follows that tomatoes and cucumbers are fruits.

Classification and Development of Fruits

In botany, the term fruit refers to a mature ovary that has developed after fertilization. Botanists classify fruits into various categories, which can range from simple to aggregate to multiple or accessory. Not all fruits are fleshy; some, like rice, wheat, and nuts, are examples of dry fruit. In addition to housing the seeds, fruits play a crucial role in the dispersal of seeds by various methods, including wind, water, and by animals.

Mature fruits can be described as fleshy or dry. While fruits like berries, peaches, apples, and grapes are considered fleshy, tomatoes and cucumbers are also technically fruits because they bear seeds and result from the enlarged ovary tissue. The miscellaneous nature of fruit categorization often leads to common foods being mistakenly labeled as vegetables when they are, in fact, fruits.

Understanding the biological definitions and classifications of plants and their parts, such as seeds and fruit, is crucial in comprehending the broader concepts in plant biology and agriculture.

User Wanny Miarelli
by
8.5k points