74.8k views
2 votes
If you were a part of a group drafting a new constitution for the United States today, which of the sources used by the Framers would you rely on in your deliberations? What other sources might you consult ? Why?

User Daryn
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

In drafting a new constitution today, I would use foundational documents like the Magna Carta, analyses of historical republics, and the writings of influential philosophers as sources.

Additionally, modern constitutions, international human rights documents, and input from a broad range of contemporary experts would be considered to ensure the new constitution is comprehensive, forward-looking, and adaptive.

Step-by-step explanation:

If I were part of a group drafting a new constitution for the United States today, I would rely on several sources that the framers used in the original deliberations. This includes historical documents like the Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights, and the works of philosophers such as John Locke, who influenced ideas on natural rights and government by consent. Additionally, the experiences under the Articles of Confederation provided valuable lessons on the need for a stronger federal government, and the successes and failures of the Roman Republic and Greek democracy offered insights into the functioning of a republic.

Other modern sources to consult would include more recent constitutions from around the world, which could provide contemporary perspectives on human rights, electoral systems, and governmental checks and balances. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights and treaties on civil liberties might also be useful references to ensure the protection of these rights within the new constitution.

Consulting with a diverse array of stakeholders and experts from various fields such as economics, technology, sociology, and environmental science could provide a more rounded and future-oriented perspective. We would do this because it is important to create a document that not only serves the present generation but is also adaptable to the future.

User AJak
by
7.5k points