Final answer:
The effectiveness of media rating systems, such as the one developed by ESRB, is acknowledged, but applying it to YA literature raises questions about censorship and freedom of speech. The balance between guiding parents and respecting personal freedoms is essential. Clear reasons and evidence should support any review or rating.
Step-by-step explanation:
The question asks whether the rating system used for TV and other media is effective and whether it should be applied to Young Adult (YA) literature. The motion picture industry's approach to guide parents by the establishment of a rating system in the 1960s has been successful to a certain point.
The Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) system for video games indicates that a similar system for assessing issues such as violence, sexuality, and drug use can be important in informing consumers. There are varied responses to this system, as demonstrated by the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in 2011, which emphasizes the balance between child protection and personal freedoms.
Applying a similar rating system to YA literature could potentially help parents and young readers to better understand the content of the books they choose. However, it may also encounter opposition based on concerns about censorship and freedom of speech. Just like with other media, the content in books can significantly differ in terms of themes and maturity, and a rating system could serve as guidance without necessarily imposing restrictions.
In any review or rating, whether for media or literature, it's important to give clear reasons and evidence for the judgment to help the audience make informed decisions.