113k views
1 vote
If a student who is called on to respond to a question gives a partially wrong answer, the recommended procedure is to

User Szer
by
7.7k points

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

To address a student's partially incorrect answer, identify the correct aspects, analyze the weak points, and offer a refined, accurate response. This process helps the student understand and correct their misconceptions, promoting a better grasp of the material and critical thinking.

Step-by-step explanation:

When a student gives a partially wrong answer, the optimal approach is to constructively analyze the response to determine where it may be incorrect. The initial step is to recognize what was correct about the response and then examine the plausibility of the partially incorrect section. Following this, an elaborated and corrected version of the answer should be presented, ideally incorporating the student's valid points and addressing any errors. This collaborative and iterative process aims to promote understanding and bring participants closer to an accurate answer.

It is essential to focus on the strengths of the partial answer, discuss why aspects of it were logical, and then discuss how the misconceptions may have arisen. This approach encourages critical thinking and a deeper engagement with the subject matter, rather than just pointing out the error. Encouraging students to revise and refine their answers fosters a growth mindset and a positive learning environment.

Using anchoring phenomena such as initially provided numbers can influence the estimation provided by a student, thus understanding the reason behind a partially wrong estimate is crucial. By addressing each of these points, a student's reasoning skills are honed, and over time, the overall accuracy of answers can improve.

User Samer Bechara
by
7.2k points
2 votes

Final answer:

The recommended procedure when a student gives a partially wrong answer is to analyze why it is wrong, identify its weaknesses, and offer a refined answer based on the analysis.

Step-by-step explanation:

The recommended procedure when a student gives a partially wrong answer to a question is to analyze why the answer is wrong and try to locate its weakness. The interlocuters should also examine what made the answer plausible in the first place. Next, someone can offer another answer to the question, possibly a refined version of the previous answer that has been adjusted in light of the weaknesses and strengths identified in the analysis. This process is repeated over and over, with each iteration theoretically bringing participants closer to the truth.

User Owain Van Brakel
by
8.0k points