41.9k views
1 vote
Should the United States intervene in Afghanistan and attempt to force Parliament to make these two issues illegal, and if so, why?

a) Yes, because it aligns with international human rights standards.
b) No, because it violates the sovereignty of Afghanistan.
c) Yes, but only if supported by the United Nations.
d) No, as it might exacerbate tensions and conflict.

Does the United States have a moral obligation to intervene in other countries where human rights violations are occurring, and if so, why?
a) Yes, to uphold global humanitarian principles.
b) No, as it might lead to unnecessary involvement in foreign affairs.
c) Yes, only when directly threatened by those violations.
d) No, as it could provoke international disputes.

User Bastardo
by
7.3k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The decision about U.S. intervention in Afghanistan to influence Parliament's laws involves a balance between upholding human rights and respecting state sovereignty. Such decisions must consider the legality, ethics, and effectiveness of the intervention, as well as possible consequences and the broader context of international relations and U.S. foreign policy.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question of whether the United States should intervene in Afghanistan to force its Parliament to outlaw certain practices is complex and involves weighing the importance of sovereign rights against human rights obligations. When considering if the US has a moral obligation to intervene in countries with human rights violations, it is critical to understand that such interventions are fraught with complications. These include potential violations of sovereignty, the risks of exacerbating tensions and conflict, and the possible misuse of humanitarian intentions to mask other geopolitical interests.

Moreover, history has shown that unilateral interventions by the US have often led to controversy, with discussions about their legality, ethics, effectiveness, and alignment with international norms. While it is important to uphold global humanitarian principles and protect human rights, these actions must be carefully considered within the broader context of international law, cultural sovereignty, and the potential consequences of foreign military interventions.

It is also worth noting that US foreign policy is influenced by a variety of factors, including the fight against terrorism, national interests, and participation in international treaties. Whether to act unilaterally or to seek the support of multilateral organizations like the United Nations (UN) is an ongoing decision in the war against terrorism and global interventions.

User Mikus
by
7.9k points