Question

Sample Response: The reason that protecting our information is important is so that people can be sure about who really sent them information. The evidence is a hypothetical situation about how a criminal could steal money by pretending to be someone else if encryption wasn't possible. The reason and evidence logically support the claim because they show one way that the Information Age would not be successful - people could easily steal money - if information is not protected.

How does the reason support the claim?
a) It provides a hypothetical situation
b) It talks about encryption
c) It mentions the Information Age
d) It discusses stealing money

What is the evidence supporting the claim?
a) The importance of protecting information
b) The hypothetical situation about stealing money
c) The success of the Information Age
d) The need for encryption

How does the evidence support the reason?
a) By discussing the Information Age
b) By providing a hypothetical situation
c) By emphasizing the importance of information protection
d) By highlighting the need for encryption

Answer 1

The reason supports the claim by providing a hypothetical situation demonstrating potential theft due to lack of data protection. The evidence is the hypothetical theft scenario that emphasizes the importance of information protection, illustrating the consequences of inadequate security.

Step-by-step explanation:

When constructing arguments, the reason supports the claim by providing a logical foundation for the argument. In the given student's response, the reason supports the claim by providing a hypothetical situation (Option a) that illustrates how the lack of data protection can lead to financial theft.

The evidence backing the claim is the hypothetical scenario about stealing money (Option b), which gives a concrete example of the dangers posed by inadequate information security.

The evidence supports the reason by emphasizing the importance of information protection (Option c). This is achieved through the specific example of the consequences that could arise if sensitive data falls into the unauthorized hands, thus showcasing the need for effective measures.