Question

Suppose that you adopt Susan Wolfs outlook: moral considerations are important, but they need not always be dominant. How would you decide when and which moral demands could be set aside? Suppose you are struggling whether to buy a Rolex or a less luxurious but adequate timepieco. You roalze that buying the Rolex is a wasteful use of resources that could be turned into morally better uses, but you enjoy having some wasteful flashy fuxaries in your life. The question is whether this is an oceasion in which you should deny moral considerations a dominant role. How could you resolve that question? Would you use moral consideration in answering that question? Could you use moral considerations in answering that question?

Answer 1

In deciding whether to set aside moral considerations in favor of personal enjoyment, it is important to consider the concept of pluralism in ethics. Pluralists argue that moral obligations are not always equally weighty or pressing, and that competing moral duties may arise in certain situations. Therefore, when deciding between buying a luxury item like a Rolex or a more practical option, you could use moral considerations to weigh the value of resource allocation and your personal enjoyment.

Step-by-step explanation:

In deciding whether to set aside moral considerations in favor of personal enjoyment, it is important to consider the concept of pluralism in ethics. Pluralists argue that moral obligations are not always equally weighty or pressing, and that competing moral duties may arise in certain situations. Therefore, when deciding between buying a luxury item like a Rolex or a more practical option, you could use moral considerations to weigh the value of resource allocation and your personal enjoyment.

For example, you could ask yourself if the enjoyment you derive from owning a Rolex outweighs the potential moral good that could come from using the resources spent on a less luxurious item for charitable purposes or more socially beneficial causes.

Ultimately, the decision will depend on your personal values and how you prioritize moral considerations versus personal enjoyment in your own life.