209k views
4 votes
Mary Anne Warren agrees with Noonan's position that the fetus has a right to life because it is a human being. True False

User Tinu
by
7.8k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Mary Anne Warren does not agree with Noonan's position on a fetus's right to life; rather, she holds a contrary view that a fetus lacks personhood and therefore lacks a right to life.

Step-by-step explanation:

The statement that Mary Anne Warren agrees with Noonan's position that the fetus has a right to life because it is a human being is False. Warren's perspective is that a fetus does not satisfy the necessary criteria for personhood, such as consciousness, reasoning, and autonomy. Therefore, she argues that a fetus does not possess a right to life, and abortion is always morally permissible. Warren's view directly contrasts with some philosophers, such as Ronald Dworkin, who assign full moral status based on being a member of the human species. Thus, the rights of the person carrying the pregnancy truly outweigh any consideration for a fetus, according to Warren.

User FunksMaName
by
7.9k points