46.2k views
0 votes
Integrate multiple sources in diverse formats and media in order to solve problems, noting any discrepancies.

Consider the views expressed in "On Seeing England for the First Time" and the excerpt from Midsummer, that the British considered native people from Britain's Caribbean colonies to be outsiders. Does the passenger manifest for the MV Empire Windrush seem to confirm or refute that view? Explain your answer.

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The British Empire had a complex view of its colonial subjects, often seeing them as outsiders needing civilization but also using them for their own benefit. Examining sources such as literature and the MV Empire Windrush manifest can provide insights into these attitudes.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question involves analyzing multiple sources to understand the attitudes toward native people from Britain's Caribbean colonies, particularly whether they were considered outsiders by the British. When examining texts such as "On Seeing England for the First Time" and "Midsummer," along with the passenger manifest for the MV Empire Windrush, we can glean insights into the British perspective of colonial subjects.

In examining the provided texts, we see a depiction of the complex and often contradicting views held by the British Empire towards its colonies. The notion of the "civilizing mission" suggests a paternalistic view where the British felt they were bringing progress to the 'savage' inhabitants, but at the same time, colonial policies and infrastructure often served the interests of the colonizers more than the colonized. While literacy and employment in colonial bureaucracies could be seen as benefits, they also altered traditional societies and reinforced the idea that British culture was superior.

The MV Empire Windrush is an emblematic example of how Caribbean people were treated as outsiders despite being subjects of the British Empire. The manifest would likely reflect the names and occupations of the passengers, potentially highlighting their colonial status and how they were perceived by the British government. If the passengers were primarily individuals returning from service to the empire or migrating for work, this could either confirm the paternalistic stance of providing opportunities for colonial subjects or highlight discrepancies in how they were treated compared to British nationals.

User Steeped
by
8.0k points