73.0k views
4 votes
Which of the following is one of the main criticisms of the trait approach?

A. People are inconsistent.
B. Traits are too narrowly defined.
C. Traits cannot be measured reliably.
D. Traits do not influence behavior.

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

The main criticism of the trait approach is that people are inconsistent, meaning that behavior may be influenced by factors other than stable traits, such as environmental contexts or internal states.

Step-by-step explanation:

One of the main criticisms of the trait approach to personality is that people are inconsistent. This criticism suggests that traits may not be fully reliable in predicting behavior since individuals can act differently in varying situations. Supporters of the trait approach argue that personality traits are stable and predictive, while critics point to behavioral variability that can result from different environmental contexts or internal states.

For instance, the Five Factor Model, which includes such dimensions as openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism, is proposed to underpin personality structure. Despite the model's popularity, critics suggest that the complex nature of human behavior cannot always be captured by a set of traits. This critique aligns with the behavioral perspective, which posits that behavior is shaped more by the environment and experiences rather than fixed traits. Therefore, the assertion that 'traits do not influence behavior' does not fully encapsulate the criticism; rather, the criticism is focused on the fluidity and context-dependent nature of behavior as opposed to strictly trait-determined actions.

User Tamaki
by
6.9k points