Question

The implied comparison in lines 3-5 (""a satellite closed … summoned to speak"") serves primarily to:

a) Highlight contrast
b) Establish irony
c) Convey humor
d) Emphasize similarity

Answer 1

The implied comparison in the lines aims to emphasize similarity between two subjects, likely using a simile or analogy as a rhetorical technique to illustrate a point and make an evaluation. This comparison can help underscore shared characteristics or themes, and is often designed to challenge conventional expectations in a rhetorically effective way.

Step-by-step explanation:

The implied comparison in lines 3-5 ("a satellite closed … summoned to speak") serves primarily to emphasize similarity. The lines likely contain a simile or an analogy, which typically compares two unlike things to emphasize a resemblance or functionality between them. This rhetorical approach supports the text's broader purpose of assessing some facet of the subject at hand, similar to how comparing and contrasting different works can be an effective technique for illustrating a point or making an evaluation.

Consider the rhetorical technique of crafting a frame for a comparison-and-contrast topic sentence as noted in Structure #2: It provides a clear conduit for presenting how two subjects share similarities, which may enhance understanding and underscore shared characteristics or themes.

Furthermore, writers often employ such methods to meet or challenge conventional expectations in rhetorically effective ways. By drawing on commonalities between disparate entities, authors, like the one responsible for the line in question, can create connections that allow readers to comprehend the material in a broader context and, when done skillfully, can both entertain and inform.

Given that humor and irony sometimes disguise or distort serious thematic messages, choosing to highlight similarities through analogies could be a deliberate move by a writer to maintain focus on the main subject.

Answer 2

The implied comparison in the text primarily emphasizes similarity through the use of analogy, drawing parallels between a satellite's function and being summoned to speak. It highlights a shared characteristic or purpose, which is a common device in literature to make a point or clarify a concept.

Step-by-step explanation:

The implied comparison in lines 3-5 of the text, referring to a satellite closing and being summoned to speak, serves primarily to emphasize similarity rather than contrast, irony, or humor. This comparison can be understood as an analogy that draws parallelism between two entities or scenarios that share common characteristics. For instance, comparing the manner in which a satellite operates, potentially in surveillance or communication, with the action of being called upon or summoned, suggests a similarity in functionality or purpose between the two.

When analyzing literature, it is crucial to consider the literary devices an author employs and the purpose they serve. Similes, for example, make an indirect comparison using words like 'as' or 'like', often to highlight similarities between subjects that are not alike. Furthermore, writers may use contrasts within their works to bring out the distinctive features between two subjects, as indicated by the structure used in comparative essays, starting with a comparison statement followed by explanations of similarities.

Rhetorically effective strategies often include manipulation through humor, such as irony and satire. However, in the provided lines, humor is not the primary intent of the comparison. While humor can sometimes distort the message, if the author's primary intent in the comparison is to draw attention to a similarity, it is best understood through the lens of analogy and the direct examination of the subjects in question.