68.0k views
2 votes
About 10-15 percent of poor readers can decode and read individual words quickly and well and can spell accurately—yet struggle to comprehend the meanings of passages. This profile is typical of students with which coexisting disorder?

a. autism and autism spectrum disorders
b. attention deficit hyperactivity disorder
c. mood disorders, such as anxiety and depression
d. speech articulation disorders

2 Answers

3 votes

Final answer:

Students who can read individual words and spell accurately but struggle with reading comprehension may have dyslexia coexisting with ADHD. This matches their symptoms more closely than autism, mood disorders, or speech articulation disorders.

Step-by-step explanation:

Students who can decode and read individual words effectively and spell accurately but struggle to comprehend larger passages of text may have a profile that is suggestive of a coexisting disorder. This profile can be typical of students with dyslexia alongside attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Dyslexia is a common learning disability characterized by difficulty in processing letters and sounds, affecting reading ability, while ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder that often impedes concentration, organization, and could coexist with learning disabilities, affecting around 30-70% of individuals with diagnosed ADHD.

Although students with ADHD can exhibit wide-ranging symptoms, this particular profile matches closely with the characteristics of dyslexia comorbid with ADHD, rather than autism, mood disorders, or speech articulation disorders.

User Andyteucher
by
7.7k points
5 votes

Final answer:

Students who can read and spell accurately but struggle with reading comprehension typically have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), as ADHD can affect the ability to maintain attention and process information necessary for understanding text.

Step-by-step explanation:

Students who can decode and read individual words quickly and well, and can spell accurately, yet struggle to comprehend the meanings of passages, typically exhibit a profile that is characteristic of students with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). This is because despite their ability to process the mechanics of reading, the challenges associated with ADHD can interfere with their ability to maintain attention and engage in necessary mental processes that contribute to reading comprehension.

While mood disorders like anxiety and depression, and speech articulation disorders can also impact learning, they do not typically manifest this specific profile. Autism spectrum disorders may result in difficulties with social interaction and communication, which can affect language skills broadly, but not typically in the discrepancy seen between decoding and comprehension as stated in the question.

ADHD often coexists with various learning disabilities, with research indicating that a significant percentage of individuals diagnosed with ADHD also present with some sort of learning disability. For instance, dyslexia, a common learning disability, can result in difficulties with reading, writing, and spelling, but it generally involves a difficulty in processing letters and sounds rather than the comprehension issues separate from accurate decoding and spelling noted in the student's profile described in the question. It is crucial to provide appropriate support and interventions for students with ADHD to help them succeed academically.

User Simon Hutchison
by
7.8k points