Question

Kyle missed a class session and informs the instructor that her absence was a result of being pulled over by a police officer and receiving a ticket. The instructor calls the police department, but there is no record that Kyle was pulled over. When the instructor asks to see the ticket, Kyle produces a document that was clearly not official -- complete with a phony signature. Is Kyle guilty of academic dishonesty?

a) No. The instructor violated Kyle's right to privacy by inquiring about the parking ticket.

b) Yes. Kyle committed academic dishonesty by impersonating a police officer.

c) Yes. Kyle committed academic dishonesty because she produced false evidence.

d) No. Missing a class is not a case of academic dishonesty, and therefore it does not matter whether or not the student got a ticket.

Answer 1

Kyle is guilty of academic dishonesty because she fabricated a document to justify her absence from class, which is a deceptive tactic against the code of conduct expected in academic institutions.

Step-by-step explanation:

Is Kyle guilty of academic dishonesty? The correct answer is 'c' - Yes. Kyle committed academic dishonesty because she produced false evidence. Presenting a fake document as an excuse for missing a class is a form of dishonesty because it involves deception to gain an unfair advantage or to avoid a penalty. While Kyle did not impersonate a police officer, she fabricated evidence to support her false claim. Academic institutions maintain strict policies regarding integrity, and students are expected to uphold these standards by being truthful in all their academic endeavors.

Submitting falsified documents falls under the umbrella of academic dishonesty, which not only includes cheating on exams and plagiarism but also any form of deception that violates the principles of integrity. This behavior undermines the trust between students and educators and can result in serious consequences, including disciplinary action. Honesty is a fundamental aspect of academic life, and students must always strive to reflect this value in their conduct.