133k views
2 votes
Prove that 3a²−1 is never a perfect square when a is an integer

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

To prove that 3a² - 1 is never a perfect square when a is an integer, we assume the opposite and use contradiction by considering the equation modulo 3. We show that the equation cannot hold, thus proving our assumption incorrect.

Step-by-step explanation:

To prove that 3a² - 1 is never a perfect square when a is an integer, we can use contradiction.

Let's assume that 3a² - 1 is a perfect square. Therefore, there exists an integer n such that n² = 3a² - 1.

We can rewrite the equation as n² - 3a² = -1.

Now, let's consider the equation modulo 3. Looking at the possible remainders when a number is divided by 3, we can see that the squares can only give remainders 0 or 1. But the left side of the equation gives a remainder of 2 when divided by 3, and the right side gives a remainder of -1 = 2, which is not possible.

Hence, our assumption was incorrect, and therefore 3a² - 1 is never a perfect square when a is an integer.

User Mark Gardner
by
7.0k points