Question

Evaluate Characters: Compare and contrast the behaviors of the nurse and Friar Laurence in Act Three. On the basis of their actions and interactions with other characters, which of the two would you trust more if you were Romeo or Juliet? Explain, citing evidence from the play.

Answer 1

In Act Three of Romeo and Juliet, the nurse and Friar Laurence exhibit contrasting behaviors and actions. If I were Romeo or Juliet, I would trust Friar Laurence more.

Step-by-step explanation:

In Act Three of Romeo and Juliet, the nurse and Friar Laurence exhibit contrasting behaviors and actions. The nurse is portrayed as warm and earthy, serving as a confidante and giving practical advice to Juliet. On the other hand, Friar Laurence is portrayed as wise and knowledgeable, often offering guidance and solutions to the problems faced by Romeo and Juliet.

If I were Romeo or Juliet, I would trust Friar Laurence more. Although the nurse is well-meaning and caring, her impulsive behavior and lack of foresight could potentially lead to negative consequences. For example, she agrees to help Juliet marry Romeo without considering the long-term implications. On the other hand, Friar Laurence devises the plan for Juliet to fake her death, with the intention of reuniting her with Romeo. While this plan ultimately leads to tragedy, it is clear that Friar Laurence's intentions were noble and he had Romeo and Juliet's best interests at heart.