Question

Select one detail in the text that does NOT strongly support the main idea. Then explain why this detail does not strongly support the main idea.

a) The color of the curtains in the room
b) The main character's name
c) The setting of the story
d) A minor character's dialogue

Answer 1

The detail that least supports the main idea of a text is typically the most minor and irrelevant to the central narrative, such as 'The color of the curtains in the room', since this usually doesn't contribute directly to the main theme unlike names, setting, or dialogue.

Step-by-step explanation:

When analyzing whether a detail in a text supports the main idea, we must assess the relevance and contribution of that detail to the central concept the author aims to convey. Among the options provided, 'The color of the curtains in the room' is the detail that least likely supports the main idea. This is because such a specific aspect of setting generally does not directly inform the central narrative or themes unless color symbolism or emphasis on setting is crucial to the main idea. In most texts, details like this are often ancillary and may only contribute to establishing mood or visual imagery, rather than substantiating the author’s primary argument or purpose.

By contrast, details like the main character's name, the overall setting of the story, or a minor character's dialogue can be much more significant. The main character's name could carry thematic weight or historical significance, while the setting can shape the entire narrative and influence characters' actions. Dialogue can reveal important information about the plot, character relationships, or underlying themes. Therefore, compared to these other details, the color of the curtains is least likely to support the main points with strong evidence directly related to the story's key message.

Answer 2

The detail that does not strongly support the main idea is often the color of the curtains in the room because it is usually a superficial description and does not contribute significantly to the plot, character development, or theme, unlike the main character's name, setting, or dialogue.

Step-by-step explanation:

When analyzing a text to understand its central narrative, each detail presented should be scrutinized for its relevance and impact on supporting the main idea or theme. One detail that does not strongly support the main idea of a story is often the color of the curtains in the room.

This detail is usually considered decorative or atmospheric and rarely contributes to the development of the plot or characters unless the narrative revolves around interior design or the curtains have a significant symbolic value within the story. Details such as the main character's name, the setting, or a minor character's dialogue are typically more integral because they directly relate to story development, context, or character interaction and can carry important subtext or themes.

For example, while the name of the main character may provide cultural or historical context, and the setting can establish the backdrop against which events unfold, the color of the curtains is unlikely to do either unless it specifically ties into the narrative (like the 'green light' in The Great Gatsby). Conversely, dialogues even from minor characters can propel the story forward, reveal key plot points, or offer insight into main characters and the overall message of the text. When revising, it is helpful to circle unnecessary details and underline areas where more vivid details are required. Additionally, assessing whether the text provides sufficient evidence to support main ideas and using descriptive diction and sensory detail to engage readers is crucial for a well-supported argument.