209k views
2 votes
Compare Mohan's way of dealing with the elephants with Uma's.

User Em
by
7.5k points

2 Answers

4 votes

Final Answer:

Mohan and Uma differ in their approaches to handling elephants. Mohan employs a more traditional, authoritative method, emphasizing dominance and control. In contrast, Uma adopts a more empathetic and collaborative approach, seeking to establish a bond based on understanding and trust.

Step-by-step explanation:

Mohan's approach to dealing with elephants is rooted in a traditional, hierarchical model where he asserts dominance and control over the animals. This can be observed in his use of tools like hooks and chains to manage the elephants, relying on a power dynamic to establish authority.

Such methods may yield short-term compliance but risk creating a fear-based relationship, potentially leading to negative consequences in the long run. The focus is on subduing the elephants rather than fostering a mutual understanding.

On the other hand, Uma takes a more modern and empathetic approach. She recognizes the intelligence and emotional complexity of elephants and seeks to build a relationship based on trust and communication. Uma employs positive reinforcement techniques, using rewards and encouragement to guide the elephants.

This approach aims to create a partnership where both the human and elephant work together, fostering a sense of cooperation. By understanding the elephants' needs and emotions, Uma strives to create a harmonious environment that benefits both parties.

In summary, while Mohan relies on a traditional, dominance-based method, Uma embraces a more contemporary and compassionate approach that prioritizes cooperation and mutual respect.

The key difference lies in their fundamental philosophies about human-animal interactions, with Mohan emphasizing control and Uma valuing understanding and collaboration.

User Peter Lang
by
8.0k points
6 votes

Final answer:

Mohan uses patience and positive reinforcement, while Uma resorts to force and dominance, showcasing differing approaches in elephant handling techniques.

Step-by-step explanation:

Mohan's approach to handling elephants emphasizes empathy and understanding.

He employs patience, building trust through positive reinforcement and gentle training methods, fostering a relationship based on mutual respect.

His techniques involve communication, recognizing the elephants' needs and emotions, ultimately creating a harmonious bond.

In contrast, Uma's methods rely on dominance and force.

She employs coercive measures, using tools or harsh discipline to control the elephants.

Her approach prioritizes obedience through fear rather than fostering a cooperative relationship.

This technique often results in stress and potential aggression in the elephants.

The difference lies in their fundamental philosophies: Mohan values partnership and connection, whereas Uma prioritizes control and obedience through intimidation.

Mohan's approach tends to yield more sustainable and respectful interactions,

while Uma's may generate immediate compliance but risks damaging the elephants' well-being in the long run.

User Despertar
by
6.8k points