Answer:
The numbered 4 sentence is not related to the main idea which is Randy vows he will never eat a huckleberry.
Option (D) is true.
Explanation:
The main idea of the paragraph is that Randy hates to eat huckleberries. This is established in the first sentence, which states that Randy "hates to eat huckleberries."
The second and third sentences provide examples of Randy's dislike of huckleberries.
Sentence 2 states that Randy "can't even eat it to be polite" if his mother makes him a pie with huckleberries. Sentence 3 states that Randy "wouldn't even go with his brothers when they picked huckleberries last summer."
Sentence 4, however, is not about Randy's own dislike of huckleberries. Instead, it states that Randy's brothers "prefer strawberries."
This information is not directly related to the main idea of the passage, which is about Randy's hatred of huckleberries.
If we remove sentence 4, the paragraph still makes sense.
The reader can still understand that Randy hates to eat huckleberries, even without knowing that his brothers prefer strawberries. Therefore, sentence 4 is the outlier.
Here is a revised paragraph without sentence 4:
Randy hates to eat huckleberries. If his mother makes him a pie with huckleberries, he can't even eat it to be polite.
As a matter of fact, Randy wouldn't even go with his brothers when they picked huckleberries last summer.
And Randy vows he will never eat a huckleberry.
As you can see, the paragraph still conveys the main idea that Randy hates to eat huckleberries, even without sentence 4.
This is because all of the other sentences in the paragraph directly support the main idea.
Thus,
Option (D) is true.