Final answer:
The benefits of being given an assignment by the Committee of Elders include a good fit for skills and contributions to stability, but drawbacks include limited personal choice and pressure to conform.
Step-by-step explanation:
The Committee of Elders play a significant role in the society depicted in Lois Lowry's novel The Giver. Being given an assignment by the Committee of Elders has both benefits and drawbacks. One benefit is that the assignments are carefully chosen based on the individual's aptitudes and abilities, ensuring a good fit for their skills. For example, if someone shows exceptional memory and attention to detail, they might be assigned the role of a Receiver of Memory. Another benefit is that assignments are meant to maintain the stability and harmony of the society. By giving assignments, the Committee ensure that everyone has their place and contributes in a meaningful way.
However, there are also drawbacks to being given an assignment by the Committee of Elders. One drawback is the lack of personal choice and freedom. Individuals aren't given the opportunity to pursue their own passions or explore different paths. For example, if someone has a strong interest in art but is assigned a job in agriculture, they can't pursue their artistic inclinations. Another drawback is the pressure and scrutiny that comes with the assignments. Individuals are expected to perform their assigned roles flawlessly and conform to societal norms. Failure to do so can result in severe consequences.
In conclusion, while being given an assignment by the Committee of Elders has its benefits, such as a perfect match for skills and a harmonious society, it also has drawbacks, including limited personal choice and the pressure to conform. Overall, the Committee's assignments ensure equality and stability but sacrifice individual freedoms and aspirations.
Learn more about The benefits and drawbacks of being given an assignment by the Committee of Elders