Question

Based on their arguments in the excerpts, Giddings would likely agree with and Whitman would likely disagree

with which of the following claims about the causes of the Mexican-American War?
(A) The United States sought the repayment of Mexican debts.
(B) Mexico had killed Americans during a previous conflict in Texas.
(C) The United States desired to expand slavery to Mexican territory.
D) Mexico had sent soldiers across the southern border of the United States.
zich of the fall

Answer 1

Giddings would agree with the claim that the U.S. desired to expand slavery into Mexican territories, as the war and the annexation of land were linked to the interests of slavery expansion, which concerned many prominent figures of the time.

Step-by-step explanation:

Based on arguments in the provided excerpts, Giddings would likely agree with claim (C) that the United States desired to expand slavery to Mexican territory. Evidence from various sources indicates that key figures such as John C. Calhoun and Abraham Lincoln were concerned that the war and subsequent acquisition of Mexican territories would bring the issue of slavery back to the national political discourse. Moreover, many Northerners, including abolitionists, believed the war was provoked by the South in an effort to expand slavery, and the subsequent territorial gains brought a large amount of potentially slaveholding land into the Union, thereby upsetting the balance established by the Missouri Compromise.

Answer 2

Giddings would agree with claim (C) while Whitman would disagree with claim (A) about the causes of the Mexican-American War.

Step-by-step explanation:

In this question, the excerpts mentioned are from Giddings and Whitman, who had different views on the causes of the Mexican-American War. Based on the given options, Giddings would likely agree with claim (C): The United States desired to expand slavery to Mexican territory. This is because Giddings was an abolitionist and would have viewed the expansion of slavery as a negative motive for the war. On the other hand, Whitman would likely disagree with claim (A): The United States sought the repayment of Mexican debts. Whitman's argument focuses on the conflict between the two countries and not on financial motives.

Learn more about Causes of the Mexican-American War