Question

Read the following excerpt from a student's essay. Which sentence(s) give a counterclaim? Many critics of the proposed law change argue that there is already too much government intervention in people's lives and that teens are mature enough to spen their own money as they wish. While it's true that we should be cautious when considering any change to the law, we must remember that a different set of rules apply to teenagers and our forefathers wisely gave us the right to amend laws as needed to evolve with the ages. People under age 18 don't have the same rights, or responsibilities, as full-fledged adultsOur government already limits teensaccess to addictive and dangerous products, such as tobacco, lottery tickets, alcohol, and firearmsLarge doses of caffeine fall within this same category. Furthermorethese drinks do nothing to improve the lives of children and teens. Wise and caring politicians should work to preserve the health of our young people and proposed laws restricting access to these harmful beverages will be an important step in protecting the next generation.

Answer 1

In the provided excerpt, the sentence that gives a counterclaim is:

"People under age 18 don't have the same rights, or responsibilities, as full-fledged adults."

This sentence presents a counterargument to the proposed law change by pointing out that teenagers have different rights and responsibilities compared to adults, implying that they may need some level of government intervention.

The other sentences in the excerpt support the author's viewpoint in favor of the proposed law change, arguing for government intervention to protect young people from harmful beverages and suggesting that rules should evolve with the times.