Question

Donna Gessell identifies two problems with the five-paragraph essay format:

and
content should determine form and not the other way around
the format encourages writers to list ideas rather than explore relationships
the format usually includes introductions and conclusions that do not entice the
reader
it is difficult to thoroughly argue a main point in one paragraph

Answer 1

This answer discusses two problems with the five-paragraph essay format: it doesn't prioritize content over form, and it encourages idea listing instead of exploring relationships. It also highlights that the format often leads to ineffective introductions and conclusions and limited argument development.

Step-by-step explanation:

Problems with the Five-Paragraph Essay Format

1. Content should determine form: The format of an essay should be determined by the content and purpose of the writing, rather than following a rigid structure. This allows for more creativity and flexibility in presenting ideas.
2. Idea listing instead of exploring relationships: The five-paragraph format often leads to a simplistic approach, where writers simply list their ideas without exploring the relationships between them. This limits critical thinking and in-depth analysis.
3. Ineffective introductions and conclusions: The format can result in introductions and conclusions that fail to engage the reader because they are formulaic and lack originality or creativity.
4. Limited argument development: Thoroughly arguing a main point in only one paragraph can be challenging, as it may not allow for sufficient evidence, analysis, and elaboration.

Learn more about Problems with the Five-Paragraph Essay Format