Question

Part C-Evaluate the use of the same support to make different arguments.

Recall that Nixon and Kennedy both reference statistics about the Soviet Union's gross national product (GNP) and fac
about health insurance. Analyze how the candidates use the information to arrive at different conclusions or achieve
different ends. Answer these questions in your analysis:
• How do the candidates' interpretations of the evidence differ?
Which speaker do you believe makes a more effective argument based on that evidence, and why?
.
TIP: Many arguments center on disagreements about basic facts, but in this case, Nixon and Kennedy generally agree
the same information. They just draw different conclusions about what that information means.

Answer 1

In their arguments, Nixon and Kennedy use the same support but arrive at different conclusions. Nixon emphasizes the need for increased military spending, while Kennedy focuses on domestic policies and the economic threat of the Soviet Union. The effectiveness of their arguments depends on individual perspectives.

Step-by-step explanation:

In their arguments, both Nixon and Kennedy reference statistics about the Soviet Union's gross national product (GNP) and facts about health insurance. However, the candidates interpret this information differently and arrive at different conclusions. Nixon emphasizes the high GNP of the Soviet Union to argue for the need for increased military spending and a strong defense against communist threats. Kennedy, on the other hand, uses the same statistics to highlight the potential threat of the Soviet Union's economic growth and argues for the importance of improving the U.S. economy and domestic policies, including health insurance.

While both candidates use the same support, their interpretations of the evidence differ based on their different perspectives and policy objectives. As for who makes a more effective argument, it ultimately depends on the individual's perspective and priorities. Some may find Nixon's focus on defense a compelling argument, while others may resonate more with Kennedy's emphasis on domestic policies and the potential challenges posed by the Soviet Union's economic growth.

Learn more about Candidates' use of the same support to make different arguments