229k views
3 votes
Find the mistake in the following set of steps in a student's attempt to solve 5x + 2 ≥ x + 2/5, for x. What is the correct solution set?    5x + 2 ≥ x + 2/5   5(x + 2/5) ≥ x + 2/5      (factoring out 5 on the left side)   5 ≥ 1                             (dividing by (x + 2/5))   So, the solution set is the empty set.    Find the mistake and explain.

User Brissmyr
by
7.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

In the given steps, the mistake occurs when the student divides both sides of the inequality by (x + 2/5). Let's go through the steps and explain why it is incorrect:

1. Start with the inequality: 5x + 2 ≥ x + 2/5

2. The student tries to factor out 5 on the left side: 5(x + 2/5) ≥ x + 2/5

3. Now, the mistake happens. Dividing both sides by (x + 2/5) is not valid. When dividing inequalities, we need to consider the sign of the divisor.

To understand why, let's consider a simple example: 2 > 1. If we divide both sides by 1, we get 2/1 > 1/1, which is still true. However, if we divide both sides by 2, we get 2/2 > 1/2, which is not true. Dividing by a variable or an expression that could be zero or change signs can introduce extraneous solutions.

4. Therefore, dividing both sides by (x + 2/5) is incorrect.

To find the correct solution set, we need to follow a different approach:

1. Start with the inequality: 5x + 2 ≥ x + 2/5

2. Subtract x from both sides to isolate the variable term: 5x - x + 2 ≥ x - x + 2/5, which simplifies to 4x + 2 ≥ 2/5.

3. Now, subtract 2 from both sides to isolate the variable term: 4x + 2 - 2 ≥ 2/5 - 2, which simplifies to 4x ≥ 2/5 - 2.

4. Simplify the right side: 2/5 - 2 = -10/5 + 2/5 = -8/5.

5. Divide both sides by 4 to solve for x: (4x)/4 ≥ (-8/5)/4, which simplifies to x ≥ -2/5.

6. So, the correct solution set is x ≥ -2/5.

To summarize, the mistake in the student's steps is dividing both sides of the inequality by (x + 2/5). The correct solution set is x ≥ -2/5.

User Funkizer
by
7.3k points