222k views
2 votes
Why has Locke’s philosophy toward wealth, which strongly influenced the American Founding Fathers, been criticized?

1 Answer

5 votes

Answer:

Although Locke's views on wealth had a profound impact on the American Founding Fathers, they have been criticized over the past years. Locke's theory of property, which states that people have an inherent right to acquire and hold property, has been heavily criticized since it is generally perceived as providing cover for economic inequality and providing cover for the amassing of riches by a few at the expense of the many. According to its detractors, this view ignores the impact of social and economic systems on inequality in the allocation of resources.

Another charge leveled against Locke's approach to wealth is that it puts private interests and property protection ahead of the common good. This view may overlook the part played by governments in controlling economic activity and distributing the fruits of prosperity more fairly.

Others have pointed out that Locke's theory of property is founded on a definition of property that is overly restricted, privileging material possessions above intangibles like natural beauty or cultural traditions. Because of its narrow scope, this concept can lead to the irresponsible use of natural resources and the destruction of cultural items that have lasting value.

Although Locke's views on wealth had a significant impact on the formation of the American political and economic systems, they have been roundly criticized for their potential to rationalize economic inequality, elevate the pursuit of personal gain over the common good, and fail to take into account significant non-material resources.

Sources:

  • John Locke's "Second Treatise of Government," particularly Chapter 5, which outlines his theory of property and the natural right to acquire and own property.
  • "The Wealth of Nations" by Adam Smith, which elaborated on the concept of the invisible hand of the market and its ability to promote economic growth and efficiency.
  • "The Common Good" by Robert Reich, which critiques the prioritization of individualism over the common good in American political and economic systems.
  • "Reconstructing the Commons: The Politics of Environmental Knowledge" edited by Brian Wynne, which explores the limitations of property rights and the need to consider non-material resources in environmental decision-making.
  • "The Great Leveler: Capitalism and Competition in the Court of Law" by Brett Christophers, which analyzes the role of law and legal institutions in shaping economic inequality and the distribution of wealth.
User Wolmi
by
6.5k points