179k views
3 votes
In your own words, explain the difference between pressuption and entailment and use examples to clarify the difference​

2 Answers

3 votes

Answer:

Presupposition and entailment are both concepts in semantics that relate to the meaning of linguistic expressions. While they are related, they differ in their specific focus.

Presupposition refers to the background assumptions or beliefs that are necessary for an utterance to make sense. These assumptions are not explicitly stated in the utterance, but are instead taken for granted by the speaker and listener. In other words, a presupposition is something that is assumed to be true or existing, without the speaker explicitly saying so.

Entailment, on the other hand, refers to the logical relationship between two sentences, where the meaning of one sentence implies the meaning of another sentence. In other words, if a sentence A entails sentence B, then the truth of sentence A guarantees the truth of sentence B.

For example, consider the sentence "John ate some of the cookies." This sentence entails the sentence "Some cookies were eaten by John." This is because the meaning of the first sentence logically implies the meaning of the second sentence. If John ate some of the cookies, then it must be true that some cookies were eaten by John.

In summary, the key difference between presupposition and entailment is that presupposition refers to the background assumptions or beliefs that are necessary for an utterance to make sense, while entailment refers to the logical relationship between two sentences where the meaning of one sentence implies the meaning of another sentence.

Step-by-step explanation:

User David Hedlund
by
8.7k points
4 votes

Step-by-step explanation:

Presupposition and entailment are two concepts in linguistics that refer to the different types of meaning conveyed by language.

Presupposition refers to the assumptions that a speaker makes about the world or the knowledge that the listener already has. In other words, a presupposition is something that is taken for granted or assumed to be true in a statement, even if it is not explicitly stated. For example, if I say "John's new car needs a new engine," the presupposition is that John has a car.

Entailment, on the other hand, refers to the logical implications that are necessarily conveyed by a statement. It is the information that can be inferred from a statement based on the logical relationship between the words used. For example, if I say "All dogs are animals," the entailment is that any specific dog I am referring to is also an animal.

The key difference between presupposition and entailment is that presupposition is about what the speaker assumes to be true, while entailment is about what is necessarily implied by the statement itself. Presupposition can often be hidden and inferred from context, while entailment is more explicitly conveyed by the statement.

To illustrate the difference, consider the following example: "John stopped eating meat." The presupposition is that John used to eat meat before. The entailment is that John is now a vegetarian. In this case, the presupposition is something that is not explicitly stated but can be inferred from the statement, while the entailment is the logical implication that necessarily follows from the statement.

User Juan Ayala
by
7.8k points