166k views
5 votes
Write an argumentative claim based on the following prompt:Write an essay in which you state your position on whether or not college athletes should be paid for playing.

User Cheng
by
7.8k points

1 Answer

3 votes

The issue of whether or not college athletes should be paid for playing has been a topic of heated debate in recent years. While some argue that student-athletes receive ample benefits already, including scholarships and exposure to professional leagues, others contend that their contributions to the multi-billion dollar industry of college sports warrant financial compensation. In this essay, I will argue that college athletes should be paid for playing.

First and foremost, college athletes contribute significantly to the financial success of their schools and the larger college sports industry. According to Forbes, college sports generate over $14 billion annually, with top football programs alone bringing in hundreds of millions of dollars each year. Meanwhile, student-athletes are not allowed to receive any compensation beyond their scholarships, despite the fact that their performance on the field or court is directly tied to their schools’ financial success. This is a clear inequity that needs to be addressed.

Additionally, many student-athletes face financial hardship due to their dedication to their sport. As a result of the rigorous demands of their athletic commitments, many college athletes are unable to hold part-time jobs or pursue other sources of income. This can lead to financial instability, particularly for athletes who come from low-income backgrounds. Paying college athletes would not only address this injustice, but also provide them with some measure of financial security and allow them to focus more fully on their athletic and academic pursuits.

Furthermore, the NCAA’s current rules on amateurism are arbitrary and outdated. While student-athletes are not allowed to receive payment for playing their sport, they are allowed to receive compensation for other forms of work, such as modeling or selling autographs. This creates an uneven playing field and highlights the need for a more equitable system that allows student-athletes to receive payment for their athletic contributions.

Some argue that college athletes already receive ample benefits, including scholarships, room and board, and exposure to professional leagues. However, these benefits do not fully account for the financial and time commitments required of college athletes. Moreover, not all student-athletes receive full scholarships, and many athletes from low-income backgrounds struggle to cover the cost of living expenses not covered by their scholarships.

In conclusion, college athletes should be paid for playing because they contribute significantly to the multi-billion dollar industry of college sports, and their dedication to their sport often hinders their ability to work outside of their athletic commitments, leading to financial hardship. The current system of amateurism is outdated and unjust, and it is time for a more equitable model that compensates college athletes for their athletic contributions. By paying college athletes, we can create a fairer, more just system that supports the well-being and success of student-athletes.

User Koger
by
6.9k points