Final answer:
The evidence suggesting Colonel Pinner's controlling nature includes his requirement for familial permission for actions, dictating his daughters' attire, and the strict management of his plantation.
Step-by-step explanation:
The evidence that most strongly indicates Colonel Pinner was a controlling person can be inferred from several points described in the passages. Exhibit B, which states that the sisters had difficulty taking any action without his permission, speaks to the control he exerted over his family's autonomy. Exhibit C, where he refused to let his daughters wear any color except black, even to bed, also signifies strict control over personal choices related to their appearance. Lastly, Exhibit E suggests his controlling nature through his management of the plantation, employing strategies such as tarring the fence to prevent his slaves from taking fruit from his garden, and whipping those who disobeyed.