63.5k views
4 votes
INSTRUCTIONS: THOROUGHLY ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS, BASED ON "HARRISON BERGERON", AS WELL AS THE CURRENT SOCIETY IN REAL LIFE. YOUR RESPONSES MUST BE SUPPORTED WITH EVIDENCE FROM THE TEXT, AS WELL AS YOUR OWN EXPERIENCES, EXPERIENCES YOU HAVE WITNESSED OR HEARD ABOUT WITHIN YOUR COMMUNITY, OR INCIDENTS YOU HAVE LEARNED ABOUT THROUGH NEWS STORIES.

EXPLAIN what Vonnegut is saying about improving society by making everyone average. Describe the danger in prohibiting people from expressing themselves, demonstrating their best talents and striving for their highest success. Support your opinion with evidence from the story.


What do YOU think the world would be like if everyone were the

same—average in intelligence, talents, appearance, and strength—

and no one was better than anyone else? Explain how this would differ from how people treat each other in real life.


How do you think people would feel and act toward each other? Would they be happy and satisfied? Why or why not?

User NCrazed
by
5.9k points

1 Answer

1 vote

In "Harrison Bergeron," Vonnegut is criticizing the idea of achieving equality by making everyone the same. The story shows the dangers of this approach, as it results in a society that is oppressive and joyless. In the story, people are forced to wear handicaps that limit their abilities to ensure that everyone is the same. For example, Harrison, who is exceptionally intelligent and talented, is forced to wear heavy weights to bring him down to the level of others. The story shows that when people are not allowed to express themselves or demonstrate their best talents, society suffers. This is evident in the lack of creativity, innovation, and progress in the society depicted in the story.

This idea is relevant to our current society, as many people today advocate for equal outcomes and opportunities for everyone. While this is a worthy goal, we must be careful not to go too far in the pursuit of equality. We must ensure that people are still free to express themselves and strive for their highest success. This is necessary for a healthy and prosperous society.

If everyone were the same, it would create a very dull and monotonous world. In real life, people are diverse and unique, and this is what makes the world interesting and exciting. People have different talents, interests, and abilities, and this allows for a wide range of perspectives and experiences. In a world where everyone is the same, there would be no diversity of thought, no variety of experiences, and no opportunity for people to learn from each other.

Additionally, if everyone were the same, it is likely that people would become resentful and jealous of those who are slightly better than them in some way. This could lead to a society where people are constantly trying to bring others down to their level rather than working to improve themselves.

People in a world where everyone is the same would likely feel frustrated, bored, and unfulfilled. They would not have the opportunity to express their individuality or strive for their highest success. Without the ability to differentiate themselves from others, people would not have a sense of purpose or achievement. Additionally, people would likely feel constrained and limited in their abilities, which could lead to a sense of hopelessness and despair. In contrast, people in real life are able to celebrate their unique talents and abilities, and this can lead to a sense of pride and fulfillment. While people still face challenges and inequalities, they also have the ability to overcome them and achieve their goals, which can lead to a sense of satisfaction and happiness.

User Banoffee
by
7.1k points