61.2k views
5 votes
Out of 1000 students who appeared for Cost accounting examinations,750 failed in maths,600 failed in accounts and 600 in costing,150 failed in both accounts and costing,450 failed in both maths and accounts,400 failed in both maths and costing.the students who failed all three subjects were 75.Prove that the above data is not correct​

1 Answer

3 votes

Answer: This data can be proven to be incorrect using the Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion.

The Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion states that for two events A and B, the number of elements in the union of A and B is equal to the sum of the number of elements in A and the number of elements in B minus the number of elements in their intersection.

Let's denote the number of students who failed in Maths as M, Accounts as A, and Costing as C.

From the information given, we have the following relationships:

M = 750

A = 600

C = 600

A ∩ C = 150

M ∩ A = 450

M ∩ C = 400

M ∩ A ∩ C = 75

Applying the Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion, the number of students who failed in at least one subject is:

M + A + C - (A ∩ C) - (M ∩ A) - (M ∩ C) + (M ∩ A ∩ C) = 750 + 600 + 600 - 150 - 450 - 400 + 75 = 925

However, the number of students who appeared for the exams is 1000, which means that the number of students who passed in all subjects should be 1000 - 925 = 75.

But we have already determined that the number of students who failed in all subjects is 75, which means that there are 75 students who are counted twice. This leads to a contradiction, and therefore the data given cannot be correct.

Explanation:

User Juanjo Martinez
by
7.0k points