Answer: Ariana's is incorrect in her cauculation
Explanation:
For every time that Ariana brother washed dishes, Ariana washed dishes 4 times. This tells that the the times they washed dishes occur in the ratio 4:1. If Ariana's brother washed dishes 8 times, Ariana has to have washed dishes 4x8=32 times. The way Ariana's is doing the calculation implies that his brother washed dishes 3*x=24 times. He calculation yields a wrong result.