195k views
5 votes
Compare the following well-formed translations with grammatically incorrect sentences (indicated with an asterisk at the beginning) and note any patterns you recognize:

I am studying Spanish.
Yo estoy estudiando español.

*Yo soy estudiando español.

They are sleeping today.

Ellos están durmiendo hoy.

*Ellos están dormir hoy.

You are eating bread.

Tú estás comiendo pan.

*Tú eres comiendo pan.

I am eating bread.

Estoy comiendo pan.

*Soy comiendo pan.

I am reading a book.

Estoy leyendo un libro.

*Soy leyendo un libro.

1 Answer

4 votes

The pattern that is recognized in these examples is that the grammatically correct translations use the present progressive verb conjugation (estar + gerund) while the grammatically incorrect translations use the present simple verb conjugation (ser + gerund).

In Spanish, the present progressive verb conjugation is used to express actions that are currently happening, while the present simple verb conjugation is used to express a state of being or a habit. For example, "estoy comiendo" (I am eating) is used to express that someone is currently eating at the moment, while "soy comiendo" (I am eating) is grammatically incorrect and does not make sense in this context.

Additionally, in the first set of examples, the grammatically correct translations use the pronoun that match the subject of the sentence, whereas the grammatically incorrect translations do not match the subject of the sentence.

In conclusion, it is important to use the appropriate verb conjugation and pronoun according to the context in order to form grammatically correct sentences in Spanish.

User DEfusion
by
7.4k points