112k views
2 votes
"In reference to the motivations behind her revolutionary act, Claudette Colvin said, “History had me glued to the seat.” In a 200 word essay, compare Claudette Colvin’s motivations for action with Lady Macbeth’s motivations in convincing Macbeth to murder Duncan. In what ways are they similar? In what ways are they different? In what ways are their genders referenced and drawn upon in the text to inform their motivation? Use specific text evidence to support your analysis."

1 Answer

1 vote

Claudette Colvin and Lady Macbeth are two very different characters, but they share some similarities in their motivations for action. Both Claudette and Lady Macbeth are driven by a strong desire for change and a belief in their own power to bring it about. For Claudette, it was the injustices of segregation and the struggle for civil rights that motivated her to take a stand and refuse to give up her seat on a bus in Montgomery, Alabama. For Lady Macbeth, it is her ambition and desire for power that drives her to convince Macbeth to murder Duncan, the king of Scotland.

One of the key differences between Claudette and Lady Macbeth is the nature of their actions. Claudette's actions are nonviolent and rooted in a desire for justice and equality, while Lady Macbeth's actions are violent and driven by ambition and the desire for power. Additionally, Claudette is a teenager when she takes a stand, whereas Lady Macbeth is an adult and wife of a high-ranking nobleman.

Gender is also referenced and drawn upon in both texts to inform the motivations of Claudette and Lady Macbeth. In Claudette's case, her gender is referenced in the context of the civil rights movement, where women were often overlooked in the struggle for equality. Similarly, Lady Macbeth's gender is referenced in the context of the patriarchal society of Scotland, where women were not expected to have ambition or to hold power.

In conclusion, Claudette Colvin and Lady Macbeth are similar in their strong desire for change and belief in their own power to bring it about. However, their motivations, actions and the references to their gender in the text are different. Claudette's actions are non-violent and rooted in justice and equality, while Lady Macbeth's actions are violent and driven by ambition and power.

I hope this helps :). I also suggest editing it and not completely copying if you are going to use it.

User TheFitGeekGirl
by
7.9k points