128k views
4 votes
Is Swift’s argument effective? What is the claim and at least two pieces of evidence that he uses for his proposal?

1 Answer

4 votes

Answer: The proposal claims the elite savouring poor children. This will decrease their population and the parents do not require to maintain them.

Explanation: Jonathan Swift, through his essay, Modest Proposal uses elements of sarcasm and irony to effectively support his claim. He argues that poor children make a 'reasonable dish' and the elite should feast on them. To support this claim, he provides the following evidence

  1. It will decrease the number of Papists, who are the most 'dangerous enemies' according to the author.
  2. The parents of these children will no longer carry the burden of maintaining them as they can get rid of them after the first year

User Ordoshsen
by
7.7k points