Question

write a paragraph that proves or disproves this thesis although absolutism was destructive in France it had some positive effects in russia

Answer 1

While it is true that absolutism, or the belief in the absolute power of a monarch, was a destructive force in France during the 18th century, leading to the French Revolution and the Reign of Terror, it did have some positive effects in Russia during the same period. Under the rule of Peter the Great and Catherine the Great, absolutism allowed for centralized government and the implementation of policies that modernized and strengthened Russia, such as the expansion of the military and the establishment of a strong, centralized bureaucracy. Additionally, the strong, centralized government helped to maintain stability and order in the vast Russian Empire, which was a multiethnic and multicultural society. However, it is important to note that these positive effects of absolutism in Russia came at a great cost to the rights and freedoms of the Russian people, and it can be argued that it ultimately led to the decline of Russia as a major world power in the 19th century.

Answer 2

Absolutism had some positive effects in Russia despite being destructive in France. Under Tsar Alexander I, conservative policies helped maintain stability and prevent chaos.

Step-by-step explanation:

The thesis statement implies that absolutism had some positive effects in Russia despite being destructive in France. While absolutism did have negative consequences in France, such as the Reign of Terror and Napoleon's wars, it also brought about some positive changes in Russia. For example, under Russian Tsar Alexander I, conservative ideas influenced by figures like Joseph de Maistre were implemented, resulting in strong institutions and a stable society. These conservative policies, supported by a powerful monarchy, a strong nobility, and a strong church, helped maintain order and prevent the kind of chaos seen during the French Revolution.