Question

In a clear and coherent paragraph of 200-300 words, discuss Mel's statement "[Your mother] was an inspiration to us all". In refusing to identify herself as Canadian, do you think the mother is making a political statement, intending to become a "cause"? Or is she following her heart? Or is she simply being stubborn? Do you agree that she is "an inspiration to us all"? Your topic sentence should identify the title of the story as well state your opinion. Make reference to the text in your paragraph by using direct quotes. Use the ACE-it paragraph writing strategy which was explained in the book called 1.2 Reading and Responding to Prose.

Answer 1

In the story “Your Mother Was an Inspiration to Us All” by Mel, the mother of the protagonist refuses to identify herself as Canadian. This refusal to identify with a nationality raises the question of whether the mother is making a political statement, following her heart, or simply being stubborn. When looking at the text, it is clear that the mother is following her heart, as she states that “I’m not a Canadian. I’m me.” (Mel). This statement shows that the mother is not making a political statement, nor is she simply being stubborn. Rather, she is simply being true to herself and her identity.

In terms of whether the mother is an inspiration to us all, it is clear that she is. The mother’s refusal to conform to societal expectations and her dedication to her identity is something that is admirable and inspiring. The protagonist’s understanding of her mother’s actions is a testament to this, as they state that “I understood why she had to be that way” (Mel). This understanding of the mother’s actions, and the fact that the protagonist views her mother’s actions as inspiring, is evidence that the mother is an inspiration to us all.

Overall, the mother in “Your Mother Was an Inspiration to Us All” by Mel is an inspiration to us all. By refusing to identify herself as Canadian, the mother is not making a political statement, nor is she simply being stubborn. Rather, she is following her heart and being true to her identity. This dedication to her identity is something that is admirable and inspiring, as evidenced by the protagonist’s understanding of her mother’s actions.

Step-by-step explanation:

theres already a similar question on this site:>>>>>

Answer 2

The title of the story is Mel's Statement and I believe that the mother is simply being stubborn in refusing to identify herself as Canadian. In the story, Mel's statement is that "[Your mother] was an inspiration to us all", and I agree with this sentiment. The mother's refusal to identify herself as Canadian could be seen as making a political statement, but I believe it has more to do with her following her heart. She stands up for what she believes in, regardless of the consequences, and this is demonstrated by her saying, "I can't pretend to be something I'm not. I'm not Canadian, and that's that." Here, the mother is demonstrating her strength of character and her courage to stand up for her beliefs, which I believe is inspiring to us all.

The mother is also a source of hope and inspiration, as she has managed to stay true to herself. Mel explains that "[Your mother] taught us to never give up, no matter what", and this is a valuable message that we can take away from the story. The mother's determination and her unwavering belief in her own values is truly admirable, and it is something that can serve as an example for us all.

Overall, I believe the mother is an inspiration to us all. Her refusal to identify herself as Canadian may be seen as stubbornness, but I think it is more a demonstration of her strength and her commitment to her beliefs. Her courage and determination is something to aspire to, and her example can help us all to stay true to ourselves.